The Hershey Movie Is Chocolate-Flavored History
Published Nov. 19, 2026 • Read time: 7m
This week, Hollywood came to Hershey, and vice versa.
Audience members dressed in 19th-century bustles and bowler hats paraded down a red carpet outside the Hershey Theatre—the gilded palace Milton Hershey built here during the Depression—for the world premiere of Hershey, Angel Studios' new biopic about the town's founding chocolatier.
The movie is sweet, to the point of being toothache-inducing. I was in the audience, snacking on complimentary Reece’s Pieces, and I'll confess something mildly embarrassing: by the closing credits, I was a little misty-eyed by the depiction of the enduring love between Milton and Catherine. Finn Wittrock plays Milton as a square-jawed dreamer with a sugar habit; Alexandra Daddario is radiant as Kitty, the wife who believes in him before anyone else does and then wastes away from a debilitating illness.
It's a tearjerker the way a Hallmark movie is a tearjerker: you can see every string being pulled, and they work on you anyway. Every setback in Milton's life is resolved within a scene or two—a bankruptcy rescued by a big overseas caramel order, a dry spell is broken by a traveling salesman pitching chocolate as the snack of the future, the Kiss arriving like divine inspiration from heaven. In the end, Hershey Park's Comet roller coaster has more twists and turns.
That the movie smacks of hagiography about the Hersheys is no coincidence; a glance at the label on the back of the package shows that the film was produced by Dandelion Media in partnership with Hershey Entities, with Hershey VP Suzanne Jones listed as a producer. Jones calls the film, in the company's own bloodless marketing lingo, “a strategic content platform, designed to strengthen brand resonance, deepen emotional connection and create new reasons to enjoy a Hershey’s bar.” In other words, it’s the most expensive piece of sponsored content in Pennsylvania history, a 110-minute ad that arrives at precisely the moment the company could use one.
On Valentine's Day this year, Brad Reese, the 70-year-old grandson of H.B. Reese—the man who invented the peanut butter cup in a Hershey basement in the 1920s—fired off a letter to Hershey's brand managers accusing the company of quietly replacing milk chocolate with "compound coatings" and peanut butter with "peanut crème" across a range of Reese's products. He'd thrown a bag of Valentine's Reese's Mini Hearts in the trash. "It was not edible," he said. The packaging, it turned out, described the contents as "chocolate candy," which is what the FDA lets you call something that doesn't have enough cocoa to be called chocolate. Hershey was among the companies that cajoled the FDA to loosen its standards in 2007.
Brad Reese’s complaint went viral, and others chimed in, including Stephen Colbert. Hershey's initial response was the corporate equivalent of a shrug: recipe tweaks, it said, were used in its seasonal edition of candies. Six weeks later, at an investor day in New York, Hershey folded, especially as TikTokers put its products to the test and gave them less-than-stellar grades. Chief growth officer Stacy Taffet announced that the company would return Reese's to its original recipes in 2027 to ensure its products are "consistent with their brands" — an admission, phrased in the dialect of brand management, that the brands had stopped being consistent with themselves.
The reason Hershey enshittified its products is no great mystery: Cocoa costs reached record highs over the past few years, driven by a range of factors, including Trump’s tariffs and crop failures in West Africa. Hershey's profits fell 60 percent in 2025. The company responded by charging more and selling less. In the first quarter of 2026, organic sales were propped up by roughly 10 percent price increases while volumes slid. CEO Kirk Tanner—who arrived from Wendy's in August 2025 and was paid nearly $17 million that year—blamed consumers squeezed by gas prices, inflation, and interest rates.
Then there's the specter haunting every candy executive in America these days: Ozempic. For two years, investors have tried to quantify what happens to a company whose business model is impulse purchases when a growing chunk of the country is on a drug that kills impulses. Hershey's answer, so far, is to find the silver lining in the side effects. In April, Tanner bragged that retail sales of Ice Breakers mints had jumped 8 percent, citing "functional snacking tailwinds, including GLP-1 adoption." (Translation: Ozempic breath.) Wall Street didn’t buy the hype. Hershey's stock peaked at around $236 in February and slid to roughly $157 by the end of September, losing about a third of its value before a modest autumn bounce.
So you can see why the company would rather talk about 1906 than 2026. The Hershey movie spans the 1870s to the late 1910s, which means it ends right before things get complicated. What the film presents as a love story between a man and a woman and a man and a town, in real life, is also a story about who owned the town. Hershey, Pennsylvania, has never been incorporated. To this day, it's technically part of Derry Township, with no mayor or council of its own. For decades, it didn't need one: Milton was the government. He built the houses, the trolley, the bank, the churches, the park, the zoo, and the schools, and when the Depression hit, he kept his workers employed building the hotel, the arena, and the very theater where his biopic premiered.
This was real generosity, and it kept Hershey afloat while other company towns rotted, but it also came with strings attached. One biography recounts a story Hershey liked to tell with pride: handing a stranger a nickel for the trolley fare, knowing full well the fare box was his own pocket. The historian Robert Weir describes the man as cold, paternalistic, and domineering, presiding over his workers' lives from a mansion on the hill—the aptly named High Point. Milton was arguably the closest thing America ever produced to an enlightened despot: Frederick the Great with a sweet tooth.
In 1937, Hershey's workers organized a union. After the company cut bonuses, reduced hours, and laid off union organizers, they occupied the plant. As the legend goes, a mob of thousands of farmers and loyal employees stormed the factory with fists, clubs, and ice picks, violently ending the strike. The story is of a spontaneous uprising of salt-of-the-earth farmers that held out for decades. It was also, as Weir puts it, "a bit of the Hershey company's mythology." Oral histories in the company's own archives suggest the riot was orchestrated, with imported strikebreakers and dependent dairy farmers leaned on to participate.
None of this makes Milton Hershey a monster; in fact, compared to Elon Musk, who also got the Hollywood treatment recently with a damning four-hour documentary about his misdeeds, Milton looks rather saintly. He poured his fortune into a school for orphans that still educates thousands of kids — though for most of its first six decades, the movie neglects to mention, it admitted only white boys. A warts-and-all biopic of the man could still be inspiring; American success stories don't need to be frictionless to be moving. The problem with Hershey is that the company is narrating its own founding myth, at the precise moment it most needs you to believe the myth still applies — that the bar in your hand is the same one Milton made, that the cup is the same one H.B. Reese once poured, that the historic brand is still the brand.
The film opens with a stylish flourish, a trick that turns a Hershey's Kiss into a lump of coal. The company has spent the better part of 120 years running that trick in reverse. Next year, Hershey promises, the peanut butter cups will be made with real chocolate again. Better read the label.
Ryan Zickgraf is a writer based in Harrisburg. He is a columnist at UnHerd. Follow him on X at @ryan_zickgraf.

Platner Says He Won't Be an 'a–hole' Like Fetterman in Senate
By Tara Suter, The Hill
Blame Pennsylvania for the Gerrymander Mania
By Guy Ciarrocchi, RealClearPA
What Chris Rabb's Win in Philly Means for Fetterman
By Sam Janesch, Inquirer
Voters Signal They're Done With MAGA Chaos
By Mark S. Singel, PennLive
Republicans: Pre-Canvassing Bill 'Lets Dead People Vote'
By J. Kramer, Center Square
Pennsylvania Today
Featuring the latest pennsylvania news
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
Investigations Today
Latest investigations news
Defense Morning Recon
Featuring the latest news
