
PA Dems Should Thank GOP Voters for the ‘Trifecta’
Published Nov. 19, 2026 • Read time: 4m
SP&R conducted an important post-election survey with Pennsylvania voters who told us they cast ballots in the midterms. Results show that enough Republican voters broke against their party at all levels of government to help deliver a trifecta for state Democrats in the Pennsylvania legislature. Results for this survey (conducted 11/4-11/6, N=598) were first unveiled at SP&R’s first-ever, “Keystone State Post Election Briefing,” held this month at the Harrisburg Hilton, where an audience of 100 business professionals, political junkies, and government affairs lobbyists gathered to hear election day insights from an expert panel of pollsters and campaign consultants. Included on the panel was SP&R Pollster Jim Lee, Gov. Shapiro pollster Jeff Pollock (Global Strategy Group,) and Franklin and Marshall College pollster Berwood Yost.
In the post-election survey, by a 44:33 margin, most voters said they voted “straight Democrat” as opposed to “straight Republican” this year in races for governor, Congress, and their local state representative or state senator. But among Republicans who voted, a combined 24% or nearly 1 in 4 said they either split their tickets or voted straight Democrat in down ballot races. This is a remarkable finding. This leaves only 7 in 10 Republicans – or 71% exactly, who said they voted “straight” Republican up and down the ballot. So nearly 3 in 10 Republicans apparently didn’t believe what GOP campaign advertisers, campaign consultants, and state party officials were telling them. The messaging [by GOP operatives] that things could get worse if Democratic Socialists took power was simply ignored by the electorate. To put this in perspective, only 2% of Democrats said they voted “straight Republican,” and only 11% [of Democrats] said they split their tickets. This proves that GOP campaign consultants who managed campaigns for state legislative races did one thing right but to their own chagrin – they turned out GOP voters only to have many betray them and cross party lines to vote for Democrats.
Our exit poll asking Pennsylvania voters who they voted for in the race for Pennsylvania governor (and why) is further evidence many Republicans crossed party lines to vote for the incumbent Democrat Gov. Josh Shapiro. According to our poll, only 74% – or less than 3 in 4 Republicans – said they voted for GOP gubernatorial nominee Stacy Garrity. This leaves 1 in 4 Republicans who either crossed party lines to vote for Shapiro or were too embarrassed to tell us in the survey (6% of Republicans refused to answer the question). This is consistent with our last pre-election poll conducted in late September showing that nearly 1 in 4 Republicans indicated at the time they planned to vote for Shapiro. To put this into perspective, 9 in 10 Democrats or 92% in our post-election survey said they voted for Shapiro – with only 4% of Democrats admitting they bucked their own party to vote for GOP nominee Stacy Garrity.
Parenthetically, there was intense media hype that support for controversial data centers would lead to the defeat [or election] of incumbent lawmakers at the state legislative level. But our exit poll shows that 42% of voters said data centers were not an issue that influenced them, while only 1 in 3 or 33% said they voted mainly for candidates who opposed data centers. Conversely, 2 in 5 or a combined 20% said they even voted for a mix of candidates (who both opposed or supported data centers) while 12% said they voted in favor of candidates who support data centers. Consistent with the poll, there is little evidence to suggest that [support for] data centers cost any legislator their job.
Voter turnout in the midterms topped out at about 52% of eligible state voters, which overperformed 2022 but not 2018. So it wasn’t that GOP voters stayed home on Election Day. Instead, they broke ranks. It should have been a warning sign GOP party officials were ready for, because pre-election polling conducted by our firm showed that 1 in 4 Republicans said they planned to cross party lines to vote for Shapiro. And it wouldn’t be a stretch to think that with Shapiro on track to win by a double-digit margin, the possibility of down ballot coattails was real. But the percentage of Republicans threatening to vote for Shapiro and against Garrity in our preelection polling even trumped the 16% of Republicans who, according to CNN exit polling, crossed party lines to vote for Shapiro four years ago when he handily defeated Doug Mastriano. So the combination of straight ticket Democratic voting, plus a chunk of GOP voters who split for Democrats both up and down the ballot, was a perfect storm producing the current trifecta.
James Lee is president and CEO of the Susquehanna Polling & Research, Inc., and Owner of The Bartlett Group (focus group subsidiary)

Platner Says He Won't Be an 'a–hole' Like Fetterman in Senate
By Tara Suter, The Hill
Blame Pennsylvania for the Gerrymander Mania
By Guy Ciarrocchi, RealClearPA
What Chris Rabb's Win in Philly Means for Fetterman
By Sam Janesch, Inquirer
Voters Signal They're Done With MAGA Chaos
By Mark S. Singel, PennLive
Republicans: Pre-Canvassing Bill 'Lets Dead People Vote'
By J. Kramer, Center Square
Pennsylvania Today
Featuring the latest pennsylvania news
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
Investigations Today
Latest investigations news
Defense Morning Recon
Featuring the latest news
